Hello! Our website is still under construction - thanks for your patience as we get it up and running!


Humble is a small-batch, artisan pie shop utilizing all that the Southern Wisconsin region has to offer to craft flaky pies. From sentimental classics to flavors one can only dream exist, we rotate our case selection weekly, and our catering offerings seasonally.

Humble began at markets around Madison, with a storefront on Allen Street opening in 2013. We moved during 2018 and opened our doors at our new location January 2019!

Humble is a one-woman labor of love. I’m Jennifer Mans - the owner, baker, and humble pie-maker running the ovens, dreaming up the flavors in my sleep, and washing more mixing bowls than I’m convinced I own!

I’m an east-coaster turned no-coaster, settling in Madison shy of a decade ago. I’m still eating pie every day, but I have cut down on the eight cups of coffee. I’m truly floored by the support Madison has shown for its littlest pie shop.


The pie shop utilizes local produce from the Willy Street Co-op, farmers markets, and partnering with local family farms to bring you a sampling of the vibrant flavors Wisconsin has to offer. We are proud to work closely with fellow small businesses in the community and begin to offer a selection of local products in the shop very shortly. We bake with natural, wholesome ingredients, & organic whenever possible.